Burnley Grammar School

What Alan proves is the huge life long damage bad schooling and teaching can have on someone leaving it very hard to get over and let go. There is clearly a deep sense of resentment about your education Alan and for that I would like to offer my sincerest sympathies for how it has affected you and add some positive best wishes in future to you.

Apologies, I omitted to include that my last comment was for Sebastian’s post, on 7th October at 14:36

An interesting post, and a great diversion to just appear during another re-run from an often repeated box-set of the Alan melodrama series.

Comment by: Alan on 7th October 2023 at 03:07
Have you all considered that Neil's original comment was somewhat ambiguous?.


If you thought the comment was a bit ambiguous then why didn't you follow the suggestion that Michael made and actually ask for it to be made clearer before passing your lofty judgement down on a second person in error within days of each other. You're not a fool, I can see that, but you are very over sensitive on some points.

I had an unexpected communal showering experience once with eight university friends in our early 20's that we almost chose to back out of but went with it and ended up loving.

Has anyone been to a swimming pool before in Iceland by any chance? I know it's unlikely but you never know.

Certainly not recommended for anyone with problems about general nudity among both strangers and friends.

In the single sex changing rooms, you are forced to go and strip entirely naked, males and females of all ages together, have a communal shower, and wash your bits with the soap provided. There are even diagrams to explain where you need to wash and everything.

Rather unsettling to us there were even attendants hanging about watching to enforce the rule.

The reason is that the geothermally heated outdoor pools over there don't contain any chlorine or other cleaning chemicals like British swimming pools do.

It didn't bother me at all to be honest, but a lot of my university mates, both male and female, didn't like it when we went over there for something a bit different and to study the geology. Iceland's hot water is all heated naturally.

I'd still recommend the trip though.

Will (6th October) wrote, apropos PE teachers "all kind and good, well meaning", well, as we only had one, and he was an old perv, I can't speak from experience as a pupil, but the brother of an old customer of mine, who has become a friend, is one, and he is a loudmouth - you can almost picture him in his baseball cap, acting all macho and devil-may-care. Thank you for being so solicitous of my physical health, btw - there is nothing wrong me me, I am not obese, and I am usually working from 6 a.m. till evening (except for Saturdays when I pack it in about midday).

Toby: PE and the arts (strange juxtaposition!) are luxuries in the sense that for most people sport and music will be a part time activity. It won't stop them earning a living in they can't play the French horn or trombone, or paint as if they were in Piccasso's Blue Period, or dedicate themselves to Cubism, but it will be necessary for them to have a good standard in writing, reading and numeracy. These schools that have half a dozen PE teachers could probably make do with half that number.

There is a further education not far from where I live that used to offer (via the LEA) a good range of subjects, including computer science, engineering, and "soft" subjects like beauty. A few years ago the local council sold off the FE College to one of those groups who specialise in soft subject, and the engineering section got closed down, and they built a big theatre studio and they now concentrate on the "Performing Arts" the world only needs so many actors or TV presenters. has it made the area, or the manners of the students any better?. In a word - no,

I love music and played it for several years, but I am not so hung-ho I think everyone should study it. It should be available for those who WANT it - not made compulsory - (and then I think as an after-school activity) in fact it might have the reverse effect if you make it mandatory and put people right off.

Have you all considered that Neil's original comment was somewhat ambiguous?. Is he saying that "knowing your place" was a good thing or that "knowing your rights" is better. Or vice versa?. Until he clarifies that, I will not apologise

I take issue with the view that arts, music and sport are less important. I'd argue they are most important. To suggest otherwise seems to ignore or misunderstand the massive value of mental and physical creativity. Thank goodness we don't live in a Gradgrind world.

The trouble with your abrasive approach Alan is that you made an instant judgement instead of asking for clarification and I think you might be issuing a second apology here to somebody else now.

The comment in question did not seem especially contentious to me in any way, it simply spelt out the basic truth as I see it, telling it as it was when we older ones were at school and how it is now with the younger ones.

Few people ever openly confronted teachers of any subject when I was at school. There was very little direct backchat. Even some of the rougher boys knew their place and the lines they dare not cross with anyone. Swearing was almost unheard of in school. When asked to do something by a teacher you would do so, not decide whether to do so.

There was a comment placed on here some days back where it was said that the people here who show their problem with things such as having to do gym in a certain bare chested style or be mandated into taking communal showers with others are simply the kinds of people who just don't like being told what to do by anyone in the first place. There could be a grain of truth in that.

Completely wrong interpretation and misread. You are wrong. Again.

What I said was a statement of fact, not a statement of opinion.

The perils of posting too much at 4am.

Geoff I apologised to you because I realised I was in the wrong and had misread what you wrote but this is, in full, what Neil wrote:


"Comment by: Neil on 5th October 2023 at 16:51
Many of us knew our place in school. Now many know their rights."

I don't think I have misread Neil's comment, and I have tried looking at it from a different angle - it suggests disapproval of rights to me. Clearly I mis -read your comment, and it was right to say sorry, but I find no ambiguity in Neil's comment. If he comes back and explains it a bit more, then if I am wrong I will say so.

Jason: I certainly agree with you there is far too much getting in the car to go 200 yards down the road - somebody I know drives her son and daughter to and from such a short distance every day, quite ridiculous and they could lose the use of their legs - like you I used to walk or run everywhere, but I think PE, like music and the arts deserve a very small piece of the school budget and time. Far more important to teach things that matter, like science, English, maths. Especially English so people do not keep writing "super excited" and "super thanks" (I have seen both of these in print several times) and also that the word "awesome" is not an English word. Two hours a week of PE is 90 minutes too long in my book, unless the pupil concerned has a great talent and desire to pursue it. I didn't expect my music interests to be catered for at school that was an outside job, and I doubt the boring old farts who administer such things would not have approved of what I did or where I did it. If you have a talent, and you want to express and explore it, you don't need school to foster it- quite the contrary, I'd say. I had no wish to play the recorder or the triangle, in the same way I had no wish to shin up ropes just so that R could reassure himself I wasn't wearing pants under my shorts.

Alan you look to be mistakenly on the attack again just like with me a few days ago. This time Neil for the words - 'Many of us knew our place in school. Now many know their rights.'

I don't understand your reply to his comment at all. What are you saying exactly?

Fred 4th. October 23:21.

Thanks Fred.

I mentioned in an earlier post how I can remember discussing, the school showers to come, with other boys after junior school. I suppose we all just had the usual apprehension, much the same as others I’m sure. I was naturally bodily shy anyway for whatever reason, so I was strangely looking forward to breaking this discomfort as we all dealt with it together for the first time.

Well, as things worked out, I never shared my first school shower with classmates as a new experience. I can’t actually imagine what that would have been like as I just didn’t experience it.

At that same time and age, I found myself occupied with all the hospital stuff, and when I did eventually join the school towards the end of the second term, I couldn’t take part in Gym and Games lessons for weeks anyway. I would just sit and watch, wait until it was all finished, then leave with everyone to go to our next lesson; everyone with wet hair, except me.

My first school shower experience, which was equally significant for me, was after joining them all properly for the first time in a Gym lesson. I was already 12 by then, but still the new kid they’d seen for weeks who didn’t do Gym, but then all of a sudden did. So, my very first communal shower was strangely like feeling alone within a crowd in some way, if that makes any sense. I can’t imagine what it must have been like at that age to share that new, slightly strange experience, collectively with all your classmates for the first time, as it was something I just never experienced. I can now understand how that must have been a one off, unique moment for you all.

I agree with Jason fully on every word.

PE is not a luxury.

I thought that your problem on this subject was simply down to the type of school you went to and the certain type of men who took you for the subject, and if they were all bad or useless then it comes as no surprise that has shaped such a negative view in you.

But your comment calling PE a luxury went further than what I've previously understood from you I think. It actually seems like you were one of those boys in school who simply hated PE, the whole of it, no matter what.

So I'm guessing that even if you went to a very well heeled school with fabulous teachers, all kind and good, well meaning and encouraging, with all the PE chances you could ever wish for, maybe never even having to do the tricky things like going shirtless and showers, that you would still say much the same things.

You just don't like PE full stop do you Alan.

What kind of physical activity do you do or have you done as an adult in the years since you last did a PE class. Anything at all?

A shower would have been seen as an extravagant luxury in my parents home in about 1985 Fred. I only got showers at school because of P.E. My parents still had a black and white TV in that year too, which was hilarious considering my father was a huge snooker fan.

@Fred - 4th October - There is a book called 'Stretching Their Bodies' by William Smith - it came out 40 or so years ago. From what I've seen of it it was rather 'dry'.

For the history - I posted something some months back on the general health situation in the UK from the 1900s onwards - if you have the time you might find it interesting to scroll back (I don't keep copies of my postings).

Showers - history of: showers have been about for years - I suspect that they started to come into use in 'communal settings' in the 1930s (I'm specifically thinking about in large ships for crew use).

A little while back someone posted about living in 'poor quality' housing when growing up and remembering the 'joy' of using school showers on a regular basis - because it meant they could get clean - these are things we tend to forget about the way many people grew up in the 1950s and even later.

I completely agree with Jason's comments of the 6th, and 'Thanks' to Nathan for his postings - always interesting & thought provoking.

T

Comment by: Neil on 5th October 2023 at 16:51


I take it you don't approve, Neil?

You don't like the idea that bullying teachers can treat boys like dirt, and that you should feel subservient to them?.

Even though they (quite rightly) "Know their rights" it still, sadly, doesn't stop some teachers going rogue.

Rudyard Kipling would have been proud of you, sir - damned proud.

PE is not and should not be considered a luxury subject Alan, are you kidding. It should be considered a top priority and vital, nothing less than that. What is more important than physical health and wellbeing. Far too many people of school age are sedentary and the last thing we should be doing is making them even more so. A minimum 2 hours per week is not unreasonable.

You cannot complain about an obesity crisis and then remove PE from schools. So many don't even walk to school quite short distances now and get stuck in mummy's 4 by 4.

I used to walk 2 miles to school and 2 miles back each day. Do two PE lessons each week lasting 90 minutes a go. Always on the go, sweating profusely a lot of the time and into the showers at the end every time without fail.

Eddie 4th, October 20:18

Oh it really is awful that the staff would leave those elderly men like that, and during visiting time too. It seems the staff were totally indifferent at a time when those men deserved and needed respect and care. I find it unforgivable. Perhaps you should have listened to you conscience, and If staff did notice, it would have only highlighted the limitations of their own actions, which would have done them good. Well done to your wife for helping them at that late stage in their lives when they were no longer able to do so for themselves. Were there any male nurses available? Or perhaps in 1996 still predominately female.

No, thankfully most days on the ward I would have appeared like most of the others, in a bed with sheets and covers, just wearing a stripy pyjama jacket. But I’d have nothing on below due to the contraption on my right leg, so I always felt a little vulnerable. My bed had a frame at the bottom, with the bedding over it to keep it off the mechanism that kept my leg straight. Since all my recent thought, I'm now really hoping my bedding hadn't ridden up at the bottom because of this, as it had on the boy's bed I mentioned in a previous post. Who knows, but it's far too long ago to worry about now!!

I wouldn’t have been able to cope at all if they’d been so unkind as to leave me uncovered continuously for everyone to see, and my parents would certainly have objected. Johnnie asked a similar question, to which perhaps I hadn’t made a clear answer, so I apologise for that.

Comment by: Fred on 4th October 2023 at 23:21


I don't know for sure, Fred, but I would imagine the "great" 1944 Education Reform Act made it a compulsory subject. I know that Act, is considered one of the great reforming governmental achievements, just as Blair's "50% of school students must go to university" nonsense of the early 2000s.

Frankly, in the age of cutbacks I feel the PE is a "luxury" that could become much reduced and taken as an optional subject, rather like music is. I know a musician who does some part time work in a school, but only two afternoons a week. They could make Wednesday afternoons, which is the sports day at university a day for optional sports and games.

A bit like algebra these days it is a subject not that many people feel the need to study and if they do there are plenty of after school clubs. The same might be said of art too.

Many of us knew our place in school. Now many know their rights.

I've also watched the film left on here about the young gymnasts. But it's worth saying this was not actually a PE lesson in school but a story about the whole culture of producing results at that time within the eastern bloc. The boys looked like genuinely great gymnasts but the striking on the leg and causing an injury was horrible to watch and the reaction looked very realistic too. It's probably the kind of thing that is still going on in the far east and China nowadays to produce sporting results.

I think it was Greg who called school showers a rite of passage. I absolutely concur on that one. For some strong reason this aspect of secondary and grammar schooling in all our pasts, and for some even now, took on great significance and still has a hold on the long term memory even for those of us who haven't sat in a classroom in over fifty years now.

As this is a history site, does anyone actually know the history of PE in schools? I think school became compulsory to go to in about 1870 or so, but when did PE become a compulsory part of the school week, does anyone know this and so when did regular school showering start taking place leading to the almost complete nationwide compulsory requirement for it after a certain age?

Wouldn't such things as school showers after PE have been seen as an extravagant luxury in the late 19th and even early part of the 20th century?

Nathan said he'd be disappointed if any of his present pupils wrote up on future forums many years hence. What's to say some of them aren't doing it right now Nathan? Unlike many of the contributors on here who never had access to the internet as youngsters and social media all over the place, your pupils do have it on hand.

Reading many of the recent comments surrounding school PE anxiety, and those school showers anxieties and shirtless anxieties, if anyone would like to message me to talk about these kind of feelings then I would be more than happy to converse. I will leave the email icon available.

If you would like to know more about me, please read back the posting I placed on 23rd June 2022 at 16.14. I'm sure most have long forgotten about it.

Greg on your hospital comments from your childhood and the dignity aspect that affected you.

My story goes back to 1996 and people at the other end of their lives. One of my very elderly grandparents was in the final stages of a long illness in hospital when I visited with family on a weekend afternoon. There were about 8 very old people in this ward, all male, but all kinds of visitors were coming and going. A couple of the elderly bed ridden patients were quite restless and to my horror I began to realise that one next to the bed we were at was about to become exposed. On another bed the sheets were hanging off and that mans gown was right up leaving nothing below. At one point both men were fully exposed waist down. It was hard to know what to do, do you go and do something yourself or not. Well staff entered and walked away again a few times and did nothing for these two men and I was outraged. That could have been my own grandfather being ignored like that. Luckily he was tucked up nicely and not even awake or aware of much. My wife actually went across and gently and respectfully did the nurses job and restored some of their dignity with the sheets.

In your case Greg I find it equally outrageous for a boy to be treated as such. Were your parents not concerned by that? I would not have wished my parents to visit me at eleven laying there without vital coverage, especially in a public ward area.

It's probably all still happening now as we write, in some corner of the health service. Male dignity on the NHS even in 2023 isn't considered as important as womens.

I've just this evening watched the entire Hungarian film - Feher Tenyer - that Robbie left on here. The translation of the title into White Palms obviously reference to the powder that gymnasts often place on their hands.

You were right Robbie, a very decent, if also difficult watch, seeing a gym being ruled by fear like that. It drew me in and I stayed with it.

Johnnie said;

"I agree with you that school showering was very much viewed as one of the growing up rights of passage, and yes we did worry about it. Going to the bathroom at home is seen as quite a private thing even within families isn't it. You don't expect someone else in the household to barge in on you when taking a shower or bath or using the toilet, as close as they may be related to you and live with you. There's a reason they put locks on bathroom doors after all.

When you are tiny none of that matters much but consider the age that you start demanding your own personal privacy in your own home as a youngster and it tends to kick in at around about 10 or 11 I would suggest, the exact time when you go to school that they want you to start sharing showers with your friends (and non-friends/enemies) and in front of non family adults too. You can sort of see why there can be issues that take hold when you consider this. It's actually quite perverse in some ways when looked at in the way I describe."

^
The above is a very eloquent piece of analysis I thought and made me think about the issue in a way I haven't done so before.

Alex:

R was a homosexual with a particular liking for boys of 14 and above. It was well known but this was the days of, to quote his mantra ¨ïf there is any trouble, it is me they will believe - not you¨